Profane #1: The Balance on a Knife’s Edge
Creative Team
writer: PETER MILLIGAN
artist: RAÜL FERNANDEZ
colorist: GIADA MARCHISIO
letterer: JEFF ECKLEBERRY
publisher: BOOM! STUDIOS
Reviewed by Seth Adrian Romo
Profane #1 offers a unique twist on detective stories and is an instant must-read. Like classic pulp noir tales, it features femme fatales, double crosses, and seedy bars. However, where this premiere shines is in its final hook that will catch readers unprepared for a thrilling story that will make one question reality.
Will Profane is a private investigator whose latest case impacts his entire reality. What begins with a standard investigation quickly shifts to a bar, with Will unaware of how he got there. This series draws similarities to films such as Memento with its unreliable narration and storytelling.
It should be noted that part of the joy of this issue is going in completely blind to any plot elements. Writer Peter Milligan crafts a story that operates like a magician’s trick. If you’re not paying attention to one hand, the other is sure to surprise you. It’s paramount to celebrate the impressive tone and vibe this comic book sets, as well as the character of Will Profane. From the first few pages, the protagonist and his world are captivating, and paired with your favorite noir soundtrack, it’s easy to get sucked into the story.
The balance of plot and character exploration is well done. Illustrator Raül Fernandez and colorist Gilda Marchisio work well together, and their skills shine throughout the issue. The character designs are well-executed, with subtle details such as stubble from an overtired Will. The colors invoke cold and warm tones, and added texture in the coloring elevates the art. Additionally, it’s important to celebrate the lettering by Jeff Eckleberry, as there are nods in the font designs that give clues to the surprise at the end.
Final Verdict
This series debut is a mind-bending read full of shock and awe from start to finish. It’s sharply written and illustrated, and like an unsuspecting knife, it cuts open a deadly world of noir bent on turning reality on its head.
| Criteria | Score |
|---|---|
| Writing | 9.0 |
| Story/Plot | 9.5 |
| Art/Line Work | 9.0 |
| Colors | 9.5 |
| Final Score | 9.3/10 |